Are Universities Connected to Local Sustainability? A New Study Suggests Yes…and No.

A new study finds that universities scoring strongly on measures of sustainability are associated with innovation and economic growth in their surrounding communities. However, the study did not find similar connections between university sustainability performance and environmental sustainability in their home communities.

“Society is facing a slew of global challenges, and we wanted to assess the extent to which higher education is contributing to the sort of transformative change needed to address these challenges,” says Christopher Galik, co-author of the study and a professor of public administration at North Carolina State University. “For this study, we started at the local level, exploring whether there was any association between university sustainability performance and sustainability in their surrounding communities.”

To explore the issue, researchers looked at data from 105 metropolitan areas in the United States, which are collectively home to 427 higher education institutions. Specifically, the researchers drew on data from two sources, the U.S. Cities Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) Index and the QS Sustainability Universities Ranking.

The SDG Index aggregates dozens of metrics related to a municipality’s sustainability efforts, covering issues such as climate action, energy efficiency and water use. The QS Sustainability Universities Ranking evaluates university efforts related to environmental sustainability as well as efforts aimed at addressing social concerns, such as global partnerships, community engagement and the health and well-being of students, faculty and staff.

The researchers wanted to see whether there was any relationship between universities that scored well on the QS Sustainability Universities Ranking and the municipalities that scored well on the SDGs.

“Sustainability is complicated – it has lots of different components,” says Ha Vien, first author of the paper and a Ph.D. student at North Carolina State University. “And we found that universities are associated with progress on some of those measures, but not others.”

The good news is that there was a very strong correlation between universities that score well on sustainability and communities that score well on innovation, reducing poverty, creating economic opportunities and reducing inequality.

“The bad news is that universities that perform strongly on sustainability measures are also associated with a decline in responsible consumption and production – measured here as increased air pollution and release of toxic chemicals – in their surrounding areas,” Vien says. “There was also little or no correlation between universities that scored well on environmental sustainability and the environmental sustainability scores of their communities.”

“This is an observational study, so it’s impossible to determine causation,” Galik says. “However, the evidence suggests two things. First, universities continue to be strongly associated with innovation and economic development. But second, the idea that universities can contribute to broader sustainable transformations doesn’t seem to be realized yet, at least on a large scale.”

“It took significant time and effort for universities to become the economic drivers that we see today,” Vien says. “Looking into the future, climate change will continue to be a defining challenge for the foreseeable future. Our findings highlight that there are still a lot of opportunities for higher education to make more of a difference in surrounding communities.”

The paper, “Individual and interlinked SDGs: higher education institutions and metro area sustainability performance,” is published in the International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education.

-shipman-

Note to Editors: The study abstract follows.

“Individual and interlinked SDGs: higher education institutions and metro area sustainability performance”

Authors: Ha Vien and Christopher S. Galik,

Published: Feb. 23, International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education

DOI: 10.1108/IJSHE-06-2023-0231

Abstract:
Purpose
Recent scholarship has explored higher education institutions’ (HEIs) role in transitioning to a sustainable society, but empirically, questions remain regarding their impact on the sustainability of surrounding areas. This study aims to examine the correlation between HEIs’ sustainability actions and local sustainability performance.

Design/methodology/approach
This study uses a linear regression model and principal component analysis to examine the sustainability performance of 105?US metropolitan statistical areas (MSAs) using the US cities sustainable development goal (SDG) index, which hosts 427 HEIs known for sustainability efforts. The weighted HEI sustainability performance score is calculated based on the QS sustainability universities ranking.

Findings
The correlation between MSA and HEI sustainability performance exhibits a mix of positive and negative associations, with individual and interlinked SDGs serving as proxies. These correlations encompass a wide range of goals, from economic aspects of SDG 1, 2, 3, 7, 9, social aspects of SDG10 and 16, to socio-environmental aspects of SDG12.

Research limitations/implications
Further exploration is needed to identify the causal mechanisms behind associations between SDG measures and HEI sustainability performance, whether influenced by the institution, the individual or both.

Practical implications
This study suggests that HEIs are already associated with some aspects of community sustainability, but greater contributions to a broader array of sustainability measures are possible.

Social implications
The correlation found between HEI sustainability actions and SDG10, 12 and 16 index performance in an MSA highlights a connection between HEIs and the attainment of societal goals.

Originality/value
To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this study is the first to examine the correlation between HEI and MSA sustainability performance in the US through individual and interlinked SDG proxies. It provides novel empirical evidence that demonstrates an association between HEI and some aspects of community sustainability performance.

This post was originally published in NC State News.